CaribbeanCricket.com

The Independent Voice of West Indies Cricket

Forums > The Rum Shop > HOPE....should he stay or should he go??

HOPE....should he stay or should he go??

Page: 1 2 3 next
Tue, Mar 3, '26 at 8:18 AM

@TanteMerle

"Defied Sammy successfully". Which cost him his job.

Tue, Mar 3, '26 at 8:22 AM

@natty_forever

I know bro.


Powell's decision to do his own thing earned Windies success as T20 team.

Scammy was too narcissistis to see that.

It was his way or the highway.


The only good Scammy did for us is getting Hope, King, and hopefully Hetty

back to test cricket.

Scammy T20 tenure is mediocre.

Tue, Mar 3, '26 at 2:02 PM

@TanteMerle

We moving from 4 to 7 says it all.

Tue, Mar 3, '26 at 2:15 PM

@natty_forever

when was we @ 4?

Tue, Mar 3, '26 at 7:17 PM

when we kept playing at home B sides sent by India, England and South Africa and beating them up (and teaching them).

Wed, Mar 4, '26 at 4:27 AM

@CCW

Under Rovman

Wed, Mar 4, '26 at 7:19 AM

@natty_forever

I see your true colors are shining through. That is why you band-wagonists can never be trusted.


All this talk about Rovmans disagreement with Sammy when he has remained and still is a leader and key contributor in the team. You and Panty Merle with your conspiracy theories.


WI 5-2 in the WC and 4 balls away from the semis and you all still complaining. This is the beginning of something special .


Hate the process all you want. This is WI best performance at World tournament in a decade.

Wed, Mar 4, '26 at 7:22 AM

@natty_forever

ok ...dats goin back couple years.....anyhow both Rovman an Hety would be a better alternative to Hope!

Wed, Mar 4, '26 at 7:23 AM

@voiceofreason

Hope will stay as Captain. Hetmeyer needs time still to develop in that pivotal # 3 role.

What role did Sammy develop when he was appointed captain??😜

Sat, Mar 14, '26 at 3:22 PM

I like the idea of Hetmyer as a long term all formats captain he had already demonstrated his prowess before he was badly manged and discarded instead of being groomed .

As a batsman he is up there but he needs to work on his fitness , in this regard he needs help.

Sammy is the Richie Richardson of our cricket he is well past his sell by date, he has nothing to offer our cricket

I hope he can be appointed to the ICC as a match referee this would give him a dignified exit.

or maybe he can follow the trend and go into to politics, in this regard he is well suited he reminds me so much of Lord Farquhar in Shreck


Once Sammy goes we should clean house ,the entire backrom staff with the exception of Ravi Rampaul should go.

Several players should be shown the door too first amongst them ought to be Chase Whose bright idea was it to make him test captain ,closely followed by Shep and anyone of our very average trundlers masquerading as fast bowlers


Shamar and Holder in

Poker face Joseph out!!! can you imagine the joy of being his room mate on a long tour?

We need to find a place for DaSilva and Rutherford in all formats

Hope in

Everyone else would be on trial



Sat, Mar 14, '26 at 8:04 PM

@ponderiver

You evaluated all the players with the exception of the Regal One.

Sat, Mar 14, '26 at 9:36 PM

@tc1

Read mi post hagain nuh bossy who nuh get mention deh pon trial

Sat, Mar 14, '26 at 11:19 PM

Let’s look at his captaincy record.


SHAI HOPE T20I CAPTAINCY RECORD

Matches as W.I. T20 Captain - 28

Won - 11

Lost - 16

No Result - 1

Contrast that with Rovman Powell’s captaincy record

ROVMAN POWELL’S CAPTAINCY RECORD

Matches as W.I. T20 Captain - 37

Won - 20

Lost - 17


Sun, Mar 15, '26 at 1:08 AM

@voiceofreason

You are such an asshole. Defy Sammy and lose the job. Hope saw what happened to Rovman, think he going not follow like a good little boy. A know you lick so much shyt you can no longer smell the truth.

Sun, Mar 15, '26 at 1:10 AM

@imusic

And Rovman still lose the work. I rest my case, as we will never know if Hope is a good captain or not, under the coach.

Page: 1 2 3 next